The Shawshank Redemption
The Shawshank Redemption is one of those films that stays with you long after viewing, so to transfer such a hard hitting, emotional and poignant story to the stage is no mean feat. The 1994 film starring Tim Robbins and Morgan Freeman explored every inch of drama, difficult story lines and brutal violence, but does remain a fan favourite grossing over $73 million in the box office during its time.
The current stage version starring Joe McFadden as Andy Dufresne and Ben Onuwukwe as Ellis 'Red' Redding remains a forceful piece of theatre, with a very close adaptation to the film. There are many moments of sadness, frustration, heartache and affection throughout this play, and on the hottest night of the year at the Alexandra Theatre in Birmingham, a stellar cast delivered a stellar performance.
If you're unfamiliar with the premise, The Shawshank Redemption tells the story of Andy Dufresne, a banker wrongly imprisoned for murder, who forms a deep friendship with fellow inmate Red during decades inside the brutal Shawshank Prison. Through quiet determination, courage, and hope, Andy inspires those around him while never losing sight of the possibility of freedom and redemption.
As you can expect within a prison environment, emotions run very high and Dufresne experiences extreme violence at the hands of 'The Sisters', Bogs Diamond (Sean Kingsley) and Rooster (Ashley D Gayle). These moments are hard to watch but handled with sensitivity for the viewing audience. Gayle delivered a standout performance throughout the show, capturing Rooster’s brash, angry, and brutal persona with commanding intensity.
The Warden of Shawshank is played by Bill Ward who provided an emotionally charged performance. The relationship between Andy Dufresne and the Warden is one of manipulation, control, and ultimately resistance. At first, the Warden recognises Andy’s intelligence and financial expertise, using him to manage corrupt schemes and launder money while presenting himself as a moral and religious authority. Andy, meanwhile, quietly endures the Warden’s exploitation, masking his growing determination to reclaim his freedom. Their relationship becomes a battle between oppression and hope, with the Warden representing the cruelty and corruption of Shawshank, while Andy symbolises patience, resilience, and eventual triumph over injustice.
Joe McFadden as Dufresne provided a slightly lighter version of this character originally bought to life by Tim Robbins on the big screen. At times it felt a little out of character for Dufresne as I was more familiar with a shy, unassuming man just biding his time and plotting his ultimate escape. Ben Onwukwe as 'Red' acted as our narrator initially and for a role made exceptionally famous by 'Mr Smooth' Morgan Freeman, Onwukwe projected that air of calm and familiar sounding voice perfectly making you feel at ease and safe in his presence on stage.
Overall, The Shawshank Redemption is brought to the stage with intensity, heart, and emotional depth, capturing the enduring themes of hope, friendship, and resilience that have made the story so beloved. Strong performances across the cast and a gripping atmosphere ensure the production remains engaging throughout, even in its darkest moments.
This show was reviewed on the 26th May 2026 at the Alexandra Theatre, Birmingham where it runs until the 30th May 2026. Tickets available here: The Shawshank Redemption Tickets | The Alexandra, Birmingham in Birmingham | ATG Tickets
Full tour details here: The Shawshank Redemption | 2026 UK & Ireland Tour – Bill Kenwright Limited
Review written by Emma Rowley
AD/Gifted
Photo credit: Supplied by Production
Check out other reviews from Curtain Call Reviews and get in touch to have our reviewers head to your show