Million Dollar Quartet
Million Dollar Quartet, The Arts at Marble Arch, is a fantastic introduction to music history through the iconic characters and legends of its time. With a mix of rock ’n’ roll classics, behind the scenes drama and lots of ego, the production offers much more than a collection of familiar songs. It transports you right back to where it all happened. 1959 in Sun Studio’s Memphis Tennessee, watching four extraordinary musicians come together at a pivotal moment in their careers. What makes this production so enjoyable is that it doesn’t feel like watching four famous names simply perform their greatest hits. It feels like stepping into the recording studio and witnessing four very different personalities collide, each with their own ambitions, frustrations and musical identity.
Connor Payne (Elvis Presley) brings a natural charisma to the role that makes it easy to understand why Elvis has such a magnetic presence. There is a confidence and star quality to his performance, but also a sense of the young artist behind the legend. Payne makes Elvis feel like a real person rather than the classic stereotypical impersonation’s we are used to.
Christopher Erasmus (Johnny Cash) brings a contrasting energy to the quartet. His portrayal has a more measured, grounded quality, which works beautifully alongside the bigger personalities around him. Erasmus captures the sense of a musician with his own identity and direction, giving Cash a presence that feels distinct, edgy, cool and memorable. Joe Bence (Jerry Lee Lewis) is one of the real sparks of the production. His performance brings an infectious sense of mischief and his confidence and unpredictability is the perfect energy to shake things up and that is exactly what he does. Bence understands the humour and flamboyance of the character, while also making the musical moments feel exciting and full of life. He is impossible not to watch on stage and one of the productions highlights.
Joey Bradick (Carl Perkins) has a strong sense of character and musicality in this role. His performance helps highlight the tension and rivalry between Perkins and the other musicians, giving the quartet another distinct personality and dynamic adding friction to the reunion. Bradick’s portrayal adds to the feeling that these four talented individuals all have something different to prove.
Darren Day (Sam Phillips) provides an important centre to the story. As the man bringing these musicians together, his character helps connect the different personalities and gives the production its sense of purpose, gliding us effortlessly through the story Day brings authority and presence to the role, while helping the audience understand the significance of the moments unfolding in the studio. Day is born to play this part and a real credit to the company. Jenay Naima (Dyanne) adds another perspective to the story bringing warmth and individuality to the production and role; she is the last piece of the puzzle adding her incredible voice to the mix making the harmonies pop! She helps give the show a sense of balance and adds another layer to the evening. As soon as she enters Naima makes her presence known, which isn’t that easy with all the bravado and competition amongst the larger than life personalities. Geraint Downing (Brother Jay) and Jacob Evans (Fluke) deserve a special mention, both an important part of the ensemble, contributing to the atmosphere and helping create the feeling of a working recording studio. Their performances set the scene and add to the atmosphere, illustrating a studio full of people and personalities, rather than simply a stage set for the four musicians.
None of the musical brilliance and arrangements could have been achieved without the guidance of Musical Supervisor Lee Freeman, What I love is the way the cast make the music feel connected to the characters. The songs aren’t just there to be performed; they help reveal the personalities, rivalries and relationships at the heart of the story. The chemistry between the four musicians is particularly engaging and is fascinating to see how differently each character approach the same extraordinary moments. Libby Watson’s set and costume design is just perfect, the set is as close to the original studio as it ever could be and the costumes are the finishing touch and icing on the cake. Arts Theatre, Marble Arch, is a lovely setting for the production. The atmosphere is intimate enough to appreciate the performances, while still allowing the music to create that sense of excitement and occasion.
Overall Million Dollar Quartet is a brilliant evening of theatre, fantastic musicianship and a cast who clearly understand how to entertain. You’ll leave with a spring in your step wanting more.
This show was reviewed on the 15th September 2026 at The Arts at Marble Arch, London where it runs until the 6th December 2026. Tickets available here: Million Dollar Quartet | Offical West End Tickets | Arts at Marble Arch
Review written by Sam Sadler
AD/Gifted
Photo credit : Alex Tabrizi
Check out other reviews from Curtain Call Reviews and get in touch to have our reviewers head to your show