Fly More Than You Fall

Following her Mother’s terminal cancer diagnosis, Malia’s life is thrown into turmoil. As she navigates the next stage of her own life, Malia finds solace and strength in her writing and in the stories that spring from the pages. Through the support of her friends, the guidance of her family, and her own inner resolve, Malia learns to face her fears and embrace hope, discovering that even in the darkest times, we can find the courage to soar.

Nat Zegree has written a fantastically average score to accompany some unfortunately lacklustre lyrics, which are still more emotionally relatable than Eric Holmes’ script. This is, in part, due to the location in which the story takes place. Imagine if Ben Platt had written Heathers. A slow-progressing yet predictable and overly-dramatised american style is exactly what this show provides. 

Stewart J. Charlesworth has designed a pleasant palette of set and costumes but unfortunately there isn’t much more to say. It was nice, somewhat creative, and pretty to look at, however it didn't have any depth to it. This is meant both physically and figuratively as the stage didn’t once change shape or size throughout the 2 hours, and the space seemed too narrow for the actors to use effectively.

Heather Douglas has done a brilliant job with the choreography, up against what seems like a difficult layout to work with. With the ensemble multi-rolling as stage hands, bringing on set and props between each scene, their tracks are fairly non stop so a lot of credit is due in this respect. 

Another mention must go to directors Georgie RankcomChristian Durham as they have taken a text which has not been edited to its full potential, and found a few great moments within it. It’s clear that there is an undeniably talented group of people behind the show, however the whole production seemed unprepared at its heart. There was a moment in the wings where a microphone was turned on just a second too early and we could hear a performer ask ‘what’s next’ before rushing on to stage to make their cue…

When a show promotes itself through one particular performer, you expect them to be a primary character with stage time at least equal to the rest of the cast. This is, however, irregularly the case and is simply done for publicity, so it's great to see that Fly More Than You Fall - and one of its protagonists played by Keala Settle - haven’t fallen too deep into this category. Settle is a vocal powerhouse, however didn't have the soul in her performance you may expect from a dying mother preparing her daughter to live life without her. She was also only featured in act one of the show, with a reprise of her main number just preceding the bows.

Max Gill is the star of the stage. They truly understand the audience they’re performing to, and have got their character’s tropes down pat. As a lot of these traits aren’t familiar here in London (with the entire show being very Midwest USA) Max navigates and manipulates the script and score marvellously, pulling at every string they can to keep us on side. And it really works.

Alongside them is Maddison Bulleyment, whose voice should be in every musical theatre song written from this point forward. Although their character was slightly more out of place, and a little less entertaining, they again put every effort into doing what I believe can be dubbed ‘the most’. 

On a similar note, I actually think a recording of the soundtrack would go down well with the younger demographic of pop-lovers who enjoy a bit of cheesy inspiration and close harmony work to add to their playlists. And with Maddison and Max at the forefront, I don't think I could resist a listen either. 

If you are a fan of easy-watch, synthetically uplifting plots likely to be found in a young adult novel, then this show is for you. 

This show was reviewed on the 23rd October 2024 at Southwark Playhouse Elephant, London where it runs until the 23rd November 2024.  Tickets available here: Fly More Than You Fall - Southwark Playhouse

Review written by Katie Anna McConnell

AD/Gifted

Photo credit: Craig Fuller

Check out other reviews from Curtain Call Reviews and get in touch to have our reviewers head to your show.

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.