A Christmas Carol

Many theatres up and down the country put on their version of Charles Dickens’ ‘A Christmas Carol’ with each having its own identity and qualities. It’s fascinating to see how one story can be interpreted in so many different forms. This Christmas season, Hope Mill Theatre have teamed up with The Lowry in Salford to perform their own unique take on the festive classic.

The nostalgic Christmas tale of a selfish wayward person has been slightly adapted in this all singing all dancing Alan Menken version. Whilst putting on a production of ‘A Christmas Carol’ isn’t exactly unprecedented, for the first time ever, Scrooge (Claire Moore) is played by a woman and now named Evelina. Whilst the gender of the main character might have changed, the sentiment of the story stays pretty true to the original with the adapted back story of Evelina. Throwing all of her focus on work due to a troubled upbringing, can Evelina Scrooge see the errors of her ways in time for Christmas Day?

Directors Joseph Houston and William Whelton have brought a Broadway version and vision to the small intimate nature of The Quays Theatre, Lowry. With pages from the novel plastered across the stage, impressive and high quality projections are used to move us from location to location with striking results. The intricacy of props twirling and swirling around a busy stage only added to the magic of the piece with the hard working cast not putting a foot wrong. Original choreography by Susan Stroman ensured the piece felt vast, grand and visually arresting.

Having been previously uneducated on this version, Alan Menken’s music breathes much needed life into the story, originally written in 1843 and lifts the entire production. Known for his incredible work with Disney on family favourites such as The Little Mermaid and Beauty and The Beast, the accompanying music brings an almost fairy-tale like feel to proceedings.

The entire cast were incredible in translating the story from stage to page. Our ghost of Christmas past (Mari McGinlay) was suitably eccentric and whacky in her portrayal taking Madame Scrooge back to the Fezziwig ball. This scene stood out as if it had been taken straight from a musical of the golden age. Reminiscent of the ‘all out’ dance choreography seen in shows like 42nd Street, the ensemble collectively were astonishing. The ghost of Christmas present (James Hume) in this production was portrayed as a panto dame in ‘Mother Goose’. Whilst it sounds an odd choice on the face of it, this beautifully moved the story forward in an unusual way and Hume was nuanced in his portrayal.

With so many productions becoming a staple each festive season, it seems unfathomable that this is the first production to change the gender of the lead character. As expected, the gender of the character is irrelevant really as the story transcends years. Moore, however plays the part with such conviction putting the plethora of predecessors to bed. It’s particularly interesting in this production to have a thorough backstory rather than being rushed into the ghosts visiting and adds to the magic of the piece. Moore’s character arc was perfect as the finale came she was almost unhinged with happiness having seen the errors of her ways.

Hope Mill Theatre productions are synonymous with having a certain charm and this production is no different. The story of ‘A Christmas Carol’ has no doubt stood the test of time but this production is one for the ages. The creative team have delivered a visual feast this festive season for the classic tale with a twist.

This show was reviewed on the 12th December 2024 at The Lowry, Salford where it runs until the 5th January 2025. Tickets available here: A Christmas Carol: The Musical | Lowry

Review written by Jordan Potts

AD/Gifted

Photo credit: Matt Crockett

Check out other reviews from Curtain Call Reviews and get in touch to have our reviewers head to your show.

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.